Character Judgments, Criminal Responsibility, and the Role of Excuses

廣島法學 Volume 48 Issue 2 Page 108-85 published_at 2024-10-31
アクセス数 : 130
ダウンロード数 : 15

今月のアクセス数 : 4
今月のダウンロード数 : 0
File
HLJ_48-2_108.pdf 1.03 MB 種類 : fulltext
Title ( eng )
Character Judgments, Criminal Responsibility, and the Role of Excuses
Creator
Source Title
廣島法學
The Hiroshima Law Journal
Volume 48
Issue 2
Start Page 108
End Page 85
Number of Pages 24
Journal Identifire
[ISSN] 03865010
[NCID] AN0021395X
Abstract
This essay examines the issue of criminal liability from the viewpoint of the character theory of responsibility, with particular attention being paid to the role of excuse-based defences. Two different versions of the character theory are examined and compared: the traditional character theory and the utilitarian motivational theory of responsibility. Following a brief overview of the distinction between justification and excuse in common law jurisprudence, the two versions of the character theory are discussed and their implications are highlighted. The essay concludes that the traditional character theory, with its emphasis on moral blameworthiness, offers a better basis for understanding the nature of criminal responsibility in relation to offences which also constitute moral wrongs. The utilitarian motivational theory, on the other hand, may be given priority when considering the question of responsibility in relation to offences in which the element of moral blame is absent, minimal or questionable.
Language
eng
Resource Type departmental bulletin paper
Publisher
広島大学法学会
THE SOCIETY OF LAW OF HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY
Date of Issued 2024-10-31
Rights
許可なく複製・転載することを禁じる
Publish Type Version of Record
Access Rights open access