このエントリーをはてなブックマークに追加
ID 49239
本文ファイル
著者
Lou, Jie
抄録(英)
Reliance principle (信頼の原則) limits the scope of criminal negligence. In medical cases, this principle protects medical practitioners from excessive criminal accusations. On the other hand, if this principle is easily accessed, the medical practitioner will possess improper privilege which impairs patients’ right to live and healthy well-being. Therefore, it is necessary to set appropriate preconditions for the application of the reliance principle to protect both medical practitioners’ interests and patients’ interests. However, the predominant opinion on the prerequisites of the reliance principle in Japan has irrationalities. The standards of clear division of labor (分業の原則) and substantive trust (実質的信頼関係) does not suit the current health care system. Also, the significance of no supervisory duty (監督義務) was overlooked. This paper intended to fill the gap by using legal case studies and theories analysis to show that (1) in general medical cases, clear division of labor is not a reason to negate the reliance principle; (2) the standards of substantive trust can be replaced by the compliance with the medical norms; (3) supervisory duty negates the reliance principle. Additionally, for the rationality of the duty of foreseeability (予見義務) and avoidance (回避義務), the reliance principle is located in the position of foreseeability(予見可能性). In summary, this paper aims at improving the preconditions of the reliance principle to promote the usage of the reliance principle in judicial practice and to clear the position of the reliance principle in the theoretical system of crime.
掲載誌名
廣島法學
43巻
3号
開始ページ
208
終了ページ
189
出版年月日
2020-01-31
出版者
広島大学法学会
ISSN
0386-5010
NCID
言語
英語
NII資源タイプ
紀要論文
広大資料タイプ
学内刊行物(紀要等)
DCMIタイプ
text
フォーマット
application/pdf
著者版フラグ
publisher
権利情報
許可なく複製・転載することを禁じる
部局名
社会科学研究科
他の一覧



過去1年のアクセス数 : ?
過去1年の本文閲覧数 : ?


今月のアクセス数 : ?
今月の本文閲覧数 : ?